# VERIFY SWEEP: how to rate each kill (coordinator, 28 Oct ~20:50)

The user asked: "rate those first with high priority right now". The kills under review are 254 live kills that have no FIXED badge and no replace flag. The list is in `_tools/coord/VERIFY_251.md`.

A's batch writes the data to `/Volumes/Workspace/Scratch/coord/verify/`:
- `results.jsonl`: one line per kill (motionQA g5/g0 fails/warns + top items, face events with FAILCLASS, maps N/17 + skipped, film length, page errors)
- `<key>.jpg`: a 10-frame strip from the trigger to the XT final, plus the XT and L finals
- `<weapon>_sheet.jpg`: an overview per weapon
- `progress.log`

## Verdicts (one per kill)

### READY
Every one of these is true:
- motionQA g5 AND g0: 0 FAIL. Warns are OK.
- Face: no FAILCLASS event. Plain warns are OK.
- Maps: plays on at least 15 of 17 dry maps, or the kill is honestly map-specific with a working fallback.
- 0 page errors.
- The strip and finals pass the taste rules (USER_TASTE.md, the house rules):
  - faceless heads, with nothing painted on a face and nothing reading as a face/mask/visor;
  - no bones or organs;
  - no rings or circles as effects;
  - the weapon held correctly (blade forward, no gun hug);
  - the final is wide, at roll 0, with both bodies in frame;
  - no body floating or sunk in the floor;
  - no obvious freeze;
  - blood comes from the wound, never from the head on a limb hit;
  - the gore ladder differs by level (XT is the strongest).

### FIXABLE
Small, specific fixes, each 15 minutes or less of builder work:
- one pop/slide fail;
- a 1-2 frame overlap;
- the final slightly off-frame;
- 13-14 maps.

List the exact fix with film times.

### REWORK
Real problems that need a rebuild:
- many fails;
- a mask-like face read;
- plays on 12 or fewer maps;
- broken physics;
- dull or static choreography that would embarrass the game next to the STYLE 3 kills;
- a rule the user explicitly rejected (backwards knife, gun hug, faces, bones).

## Output
Write `_tools/coord/verify/<weapon>.md` with one line per kill:
`key | NAME | READY/FIXABLE/REWORK | g5 F/W | g0 F/W | maps | face | one-line reason (+ the fix for FIXABLE)`

End the file with the counts per verdict. Be strict but fair. When unsure between READY and FIXABLE, choose FIXABLE and name the fix. Look at every strip image yourself; don't rate from the numbers alone.

Don't edit any kill file, and don't change badges or replace flags. The coordinator applies the verdicts.