THE SCORECARDEVERY KILL, OUT OF 10
We scored every kill, built or still a script, on four things: brutality, cinematic (camera and staging), the script (idea and story) and the animation detail (how much is drawn and animated). Watch the videos and check our numbers. Mark each score AGREE, TOO HIGH or TOO LOW, then send your verdicts. Nothing is rescripted until you have checked.
BRUTALITY
How extreme and horrifying the most brutal level (XT) is.
CINEMATIC
The camera and the staging: framing, cuts, timing, light.
SCRIPT
The idea and the story: the setup, the turn, the payoff.
ANIMATION DETAIL
How much detail is drawn and animated: wound anatomy, faces, bodies, props and fx, sets and lighting (built kills only).
WEAPONS RANKED
Every weapon's four averages side by side. Tap a column to rank by it (tap again to flip), tap a weapon to jump to its kills.
THE LOWEST 20
The worst kills across every weapon, ranked by the average of their four scores (animation detail left out where the kill is not built). Tap one to see its card.
EVERY KILL
One card per kill: all four scores with our reasons, what it takes to reach 9+, the contact sheet (tap to enlarge) and WATCH. Your verdicts stay on this device until you send them.